Dogs are not impressed
When looking at the product, I thought that it would be a good way to entertain my dogs. Unfortunately, after a few minutes of looking and pulling they gave up and never went back to the toy again. I think that the Kong is a superior toy to hide food and keep dogs occupied.

Very Versatile & Useful Toy!
The Tug-A-Jug seems to have really gotten a hold of both my dogs from day one, and so far there's no sign of them letting up...even at night sometimes...alas. Seems to be solidly-built. They've taken it outside as well. I may order a second one so they will stop fighting over it.

Weak
My dog chewed the rope in half first, then chewed off the spiky ball. Finally then he got to some treats. He doesn't have patience for many toys and this one did not keep his interest. I was not impressed with it. One of the worst toys i have bought.

Dog loves it, but it's LOUD
I got this and the "tricky treat ball" in the same order. Both are treat-dispensing toys that keep dogs occupied for longer than most other toys. My basset hound likes both toys, but seems to really like the tug-a-jug. I put his kibble in there and it keep him occupied for quite a while. He really likes grabbing the rope, and unlike the picture the rope on mine is made of rubber instead of twine. It will probably not last long. Also, this toy is LOUD. Much louder than the tricky treat ball. But, he seems to prefer this over the ball, so it gets my recommendation.

Cute and entertaining
This bottle is big! You can put lots of food in here which comes out a little too easy. When I put treats in it's very difficult to get out and my husband thinks that's mean. The dogs only like this toy when there are treats inside. Otherwise I think they don't get the rope and the bottle is big and akward.